View Full Version : A burning thirst for understanding.
xerent
08-11-2005, 07:39 PM
This question has plagued me for the better part of a week, and I just can't figure out the answer.
Who would win?
Kirby the Dream Warrior
- OR -
Rogue from the X-men
I just don't know!
BaxVarlet
08-11-2005, 07:44 PM
I don't know too much about Kirby, but I'd say Rogue would win. even if Kirby managed to suck up Rogue and get her powers, he would instantly be drained by coming in contact with her. Kirby doesn't drain the other persons power, just copies it.
Rogue all the way.
-Bax and zoma
insignifiGant
08-11-2005, 07:47 PM
Rogue has... yeah... and that "Southern Appeal."
She'd distract kirby with her "personality" and then bam! He's toast.
TheBlazedAce
08-11-2005, 07:52 PM
You guys underestimate kirby too much.
Kirby would win without breaking a sweat.
_Thunder_
08-11-2005, 07:57 PM
Kirby all the way
speaker4thedead
08-11-2005, 08:02 PM
This question has plagued me for the better part of a week, and I just can't figure out the answer.
Who would win?
Kirby the Dream Warrior
- OR -
Rogue from the X-men
I just don't know!
Rogue easy
You guys underestimate kirby too much.
Kirby would win without breaking a sweat.
Attakid.
xerent, I'm actually disappointed in you... I gave you a lot of credit in the intelligence department, but to actually have to ASK whether Kirby would win over Rogue?
Kirby ownages everyone. All the time.
Twelve
08-11-2005, 08:17 PM
Rogue vs. Kirby would become a PETA case. We would see Kirby abused in ways that nobody in Nintendo ever meant or intended.
12
That's an awesome quote in the siggy 12.
But darn you! Darn you for your Kirby doubting!
Twelve
08-11-2005, 08:24 PM
I mean, c'mon:
Kirby has got a big mouth, but who has a bigger mouth than THIS southern bell?
Kirby is cute, but is any man really going to say that Kirby is cuter than Rogue?
Kirby's powers are negated since Rogue can do the same.
Granted, if Rogue ever ended up in Kirby's mouth she would become a star and be spit out...
But then Kirby would have to sneak up on her, and we all know Kirby is not know for his stealth!
12
Ignition
08-11-2005, 08:24 PM
This is realy hard.... now if it were gambit then he could just pop hte air bag but since it's not him I'll have to say curby, because as soon as roge trys to do anything he'll suck her up and steel her power if not just eat her all tgeater
he is a pink ball of blubber...
but Kirby would obviosly suck up somthing ELSE and pwnage Rouge with it
emerald slasher
08-11-2005, 08:28 PM
kirby
Office_Shredder
08-11-2005, 09:03 PM
Rogue would... c'mon, even if kirby sucks rogue up, she can still drain his powers while inside of him... then would he be able to spit her out? Maybe she'd be stuck in him, and he would choke to death
emerald slasher
08-11-2005, 10:33 PM
Rogue would... c'mon, even if kirby sucks rogue up, she can still drain his powers while inside of him... then would he be able to spit her out? Maybe she'd be stuck in him, and he would choke to death
yea but then shes stuck in a massive blob of fat and eventually suffocates :p
Godmic18
08-11-2005, 10:37 PM
Kirby. :cool:
HorNeT
08-11-2005, 10:52 PM
kirby would fly up n the air turn into a rock and crush rouge like a bug :cool:
BaxVarlet
08-11-2005, 11:25 PM
Which rogue are we talking about? The movie rogue? or the Television Rogue?
Because in the series, rogue permanantly stole the powers of a superman-type figure, so she could fly, have super strength, and could still steal powers.
The movie Rogue could just steal powers.
Not familiar if she was different in the original comic books, have only read one.
But anyway, I'm sticking with Rogue.
-Bax and zoma
meat.eater
08-11-2005, 11:28 PM
I mean, c'mon:
Kirby has got a big mouth, but who has a bigger mouth than THIS southern bell?
Kirby is cute, but is any man really going to say that Kirby is cuter than Rogue?
Kirby's powers are negated since Rogue can do the same.
Granted, if Rogue ever ended up in Kirby's mouth she would become a star and be spit out...
But then Kirby would have to sneak up on her, and we all know Kirby is not know for his stealth!
12
However! If Rogue was in Kirbys moutn, she would be touching him, therefor depleting his power, and allowing her to be able to turn him into a star. Rogue would win, but It'd be close.
HorNeT
08-11-2005, 11:32 PM
if kirby just smashes her in one move she is done for..doesnt matter if he touchers her then
xerent
08-11-2005, 11:58 PM
A couple of facts:
- Kirby has to absorb power to become a stone. He dosen't have this ability inherintly, as suggested by SSB Kirby. Hence, all Kirby can do is fly, inhale, absorb (and copy rogue), or spit out (rogue, or a puff of air, which IS damaging.)
- The Rogue I'm talking about dosen't permanently copy abilities. (And neither does Kirby.) However, I do believe she does have super-strength and flight abilities inherintly.
- It takes time for Rogue's effect to work (At least a couple seconds of contact), it's not instant. Kirby's copy ability is near-instant however.
- Are enemies completely incapacitated while inside the Star Warriors mouth? I don't know?
Personally, I'm rooting for Kirby, but I just can't see a definate answer.
HorNeT
08-12-2005, 12:02 AM
o well nvm about my comments :(
Swift
08-12-2005, 10:46 AM
What about that big hammer Kirby carries around? It is large enough to squish any of the x-men I am thinking. Maybe two at once :eek:
mushroom_girl
08-12-2005, 11:26 AM
Kirby definitely. He can absorb Rogue's power, and when he sucks Rogue up and she absorbes his power from inside. That would mean they're just absorbing eachother's power and it would either never end, or they'd both die.
But I'm rooting for Kirby all the way, he's too cute. :happy:
xerent
08-12-2005, 11:35 AM
The hammer is also a power that Kirby must aquire by some other means. (I believe sucking up a star made by King Dedede gives him this ability... I dunno.) Anyways, no, he dosen't have a hammer normally.
BaxVarlet
08-12-2005, 11:41 AM
Well, since rogue can fly, and has super strength, the battle, imo, is even more one sided. Even if kirby sucks up rouge (i'm assuming it doesn't incapacitate her) she could just punch her way out of kirby. Kirby may copy powers, but i don't have any reason to believe he incapacitates the victem while he's doing it, which gives rogue the one up.
-Bax and zoma
Swift
08-12-2005, 12:36 PM
Shh... Here (http://artpad.art.com/gallery/?il4e5ice7no) it is...
I managed to catch the whole thing on videotape. :huh:
xerent
08-12-2005, 01:02 PM
Is that....
Is that corn?!
mushroom_girl
08-12-2005, 01:36 PM
Shh... Here (http://artpad.art.com/gallery/?il4e5ice7no) it is...
I managed to catch the whole thing on videotape. :huh:
Haha, I liked that. But Rogue looks a lot like she has a frog body!
BaxVarlet
08-12-2005, 01:48 PM
Apparently rogue ate corn before the fight, and she unexpectadly took upon it's awesome corn power/shape.
:huh:
-Bax and zoma
PhyreFox
08-12-2005, 01:52 PM
kirby, he not only can suck up powers and use against them, but he has a blue sword and king dedede's hamer.
The Cheat
08-12-2005, 02:39 PM
Kirby hands down. He is just too great. :cool:
Glamdring
08-12-2005, 02:50 PM
Rogue is the lamest character in the entire x-men series. Unfortunately, she's one of those characters that is like "lame... lame... lame... KICKS SOMEONE'S ASS... lame.... lame... about to die because she's lame.... MIRACULOUSLY KICKS ASS AGAIN."
I know little of this kirby fellow... but from what you say, he also has some sort of power-absorbing ability. Except that his doesn't drain the other of life.
EXCEPT. When Kirby takes on Rogue's power, he will suddenly have the life-sucking ness as well. So what would eventually happen is that both are drained of all power, and then it just turns into a kick-boxing match. Don't ask about how Rogue would have a kick-boxing match with a blob, we just won't get into that.
The end result... they will spontaneously amalgamate and become one!
The Cheat
08-12-2005, 02:53 PM
Rogue is the lamest character in the entire x-men series. Unfortunately, she's one of those characters that is like "lame... lame... lame... KICKS SOMEONE'S ASS... lame.... lame... about to die because she's lame.... MIRACULOUSLY KICKS ASS AGAIN."
I know little of this kirby fellow... but from what you say, he also has some sort of power-absorbing ability. Except that his doesn't drain the other of life.
EXCEPT. When Kirby takes on Rogue's power, he will suddenly have the life-sucking ness as well. So what would eventually happen is that both are drained of all power, and then it just turns into a kick-boxing match. Don't ask about how Rogue would have a kick-boxing match with a blob, we just won't get into that.
The end result... they will spontaneously amalgamate and become one!
woa......Kirby and Rouge becomming one? Cool..... :cool:
Matt 34.5
08-12-2005, 05:13 PM
- I dont think there can be a deffinate answer. It could go both ways, Kirby could suck up someone else (storm for example) and rogue would be 0wned, because she couldnt touch kirby.
- But also what could happen is in kirbys lack of intelligence, he could suck up Rogue, and i do beleive After gaining her powers he would lose his energy, and she would gain his power, then I'd say its all rogue.
- now if kriby were to suck up rogue (and as xerent says) he would gain her power instantly then spit her out. but at the same time i beleive she would gain his, now its a standoff between 2 kirby/Rogue highbred's
yeah.. it could go either way.
vBulletin® v3.7.4, Copyright ©2000-2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.